Tag Archive for: obese

Metabolically Healthy and Obese

/in /by

The researchers in Germany continued to determine which factors associated with being obese were the most predictive of mortality from any cause and from cardiovascular disease. While not explicitly stated, it seems to me that they attempted to use variables that were simple to assess. With that in mind, here are the variables which demonstrated whether someone was metabolically healthy or not, regardless if they were normal weight, overweight, or obese.

Criteria for Metabolic Health

  • Systolic blood pressure less than 130 and no use of blood pressure lowering medication
  • Waist-hip ratio less than 0.95 for women and less than 1.03 for men
  • No prevalent diabetes

These criteria are simple enough for most people to determine for themselves, no doctors necessary. People usually know whether they’re diabetic, and they also know whether they’re taking medication to lower their blood pressure. Most people have a home BP cuff to assess systolic blood pressure or have access to one in a store.

The waist should be measured at its widest point and hip should be measured at the bony process of the femur. Divide the second number into the first, and that gives you the waist hip ratio.

The Results

The subjects who were considered metabolically healthy and obese had no greater risk of mortality from all causes or from cardiovascular disease then did normal weight, metabolically healthy subjects. This study examined only the death rate, not the rate of disease. Still, I think that if someone is working towards becoming a healthier version of themselves, intermediate goals can be very motivating.

I like this study for two reasons. First, it confirms what I thought for many years: people who are overweight or obese can be metabolically healthy. Second, it means that instead of trying to lose all the weight a person needs to lose, there can be intermediate steps on the way to becoming the best version of yourself; in fact, you don’t even need to be trying to lose weight to start being healthier.

The study also found that some people who were metabolically unhealthy and normal weight or slightly overweight were at higher risk for cardiovascular disease and total mortality. Could it be that the reason for the reduced risk was exercise? It was not considered, but it would be interesting to see further analysis on the data to determine if fitness was a contributing factor in metabolic health.

The Bottom Line

This study provides a basis for assessing risk of mortality on more than just BMI. What it shows is that even though you may be carrying too much weight, that doesn’t mean that you’re automatically at risk for death due to cardiovascular disease or other causes. I believe regular exercise is critical to achieve metabolic health and thus reduce your mortality risk, so that’s your first step to becoming and staying metabolically healthy.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Reference: JAMA Net Open. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.8505

Can You Be Obese and Healthy?

/in /by

The research question that was most interesting to me as a graduate student was this: could you be overweight, even obese, and still be healthy? That question still interests me today, and for good reason: 70% of the U.S. population is overweight or obese, and we’ve just passed 40% of the entire population falling into the obese category. And it’s not just the U.S.; we’ve exported our poor fitness and diet habits around the world.

Research done decades ago from by Cooper Institute, most often under the direction of Steven Blair, demonstrated that you could be fat and fit. Their research showed that people who were obese, meaning they had a BMI greater than or equal to 30.0, were no more at risk for death from cardiovascular disease or all-cause mortality if they were in the high fitness category.

That’s not the same question as this: could you be metabolically healthy and at no more risk for death from cardiovascular disease or all-cause mortality than someone with a normal BMI (18.5-24.9 kg/m2)? Researchers from Germany decided to examine that question. They used data collected from the National Health and Nutrition Education Survey III, which included over 12,000 subjects, and the U.K. Biobank, which contained over 374,000 subjects. Then they examined the statistical relationship between many different variables such as triglycerides, total cholesterol, hemoglobin A1C, C-reactive protein, systolic blood pressure, and on and on. Once they had a series of statistical relationships between obesity and mortality, then they sought to derive as simple an algorithm as they could to develop a profile of someone who would be metabolically healthy and obese. I’ll tell you more about that in Saturday’s memo.

Meanwhile, have you examined that map that was part of the CDC atrial fibrillation primer? Here’s what I saw: I’ll call it the I-75 Corridor of A-fib. Starting in Flint, MI, if you follow the pattern of the deepest red, it follows I-75 through Detroit to Toledo, OH, then Cincinnati, OH, and all the way down through Georgia to Florida. That’s the I-75 Corridor of A-Fib. What does it mean? Nothing, as far as I know; it doesn’t correspond to race or income or temperature. It’s an observation, nothing more, but maybe some epidemiologist or statistician somewhere will look into in more deeply.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Reference: JAMA Net Open. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.8505

Triathlon Observations: Prepare to Compete

/in /by

Let me be clear: I think that the single most important thing that you can do to be healthy is to exercise regularly. Whether walking, swimming, or one of the hundreds of other types of exercise, talking with your physician about it may be all that’s required for you to get started.

Moving from exercise that helps your health to competing in fitness events requires more—that’s independent of your body weight lest you think I’m talking only about the very heavy people that competed in the triathlon. Here’s what I recommend.

First, you should have a stress test that assesses how your heart and blood vessels perform under maximal conditions. That applies to men over 40 and women over 50, for sure. But I also think if you have been overweight for over five years, you should have the test regardless of age. The maximal exercise test is not foolproof, but it’s the best available predictor of heart problems. This isn’t just me being a worrier; I’m sad to report that one participant died of a heart attack last Sunday. Getting checked out before you start is the best way to protect yourself.

Second, you should have a complete lipid profile, HbA1c, and a blood insulin test as a minimum. As I suggested in Thursday’s memo, you need to know whether you’re a prediabetic or even an undiagnosed type 2 diabetic. The best option for you would be to exercise, but when you push yourself hard for long periods of time, it’s going to affect your blood sugar levels as it would affect a diabetic’s, not someone who has a normal carbohydrate metabolism; for instance, you could pass out if your blood sugar gets too low, and if you’re out alone on a run, that’s a problem. You can deal with it, but you have to know if it’s an issue.

Third, you should get an orthopedic analysis. By that I mean that your joints should be evaluated for range of motion, tendon and ligament stability, and gait. Swimming affects the shoulders, bicycling the lower back, and running the hips, knees, and feet. Any abnormality will be exacerbated; for example, the forces you create when you run is five times your body weight. Do the math—that’s a lot of stress on your knees and feet.

Once you get the all clear, get after it. Start conservatively but if you have the urge to compete to see what you’re capable of, do it. I think if you want a challenge, whether to walk or run a 5K, swim a mile, or bike 50 miles, or combine them into a single event such as the triathlon, you should do it. Just make sure you get your body checked out before you do.

Final Observation

While I believe exercise is important no matter the level at which you do it, exercise won’t help you lose a lot of weight. Surprised? Remember the size of the people I mentioned that competed in the triathlon—not just overweight but obese? If they had put in the training, and I know some of the competitors and know that they did, you’d have thought they would have lost a significant amount of weight. They didn’t.

Burning calories helps with weight loss, but as a well-known expert once said “Americans can’t out run their appetites.” If you could exercise six or eight hours a day, you could probably lose weight without changing your diet, but I doubt you have that kind of time. You can use exercise as a tool to help you lose weight, and exercise pays major benefits in fitness, strength, and stamina. But you will not lose weight unless you also eat less and eat better.

What are you prepared to do today?

Dr. Chet

 

Triathlon Observations: Heavy and Healthy?

/in /by

The major observation I had as I volunteered at the Grand Rapids Triathlon was that the body weight distribution of the people participating in the triathlon mimicked the population of the U.S. We’re a fat nation; 70% of the population is overweight and half of those are obese. Those percentages also seemed to apply to the participants in the race.

In addition to being a regular Grand Rapids event, the Grand Rapids Triathlon was also the National Championship for the Clydesdale and Athena athletes. In order to qualify for the Clydesdale division, men must weigh over 220 pounds; for women to qualify for the Athena division, they must weigh over 165 pounds. Based on my observations, a majority of the participants would have qualified for that category, whether that was their intention or not.

There were men well over 300 pounds and women over 250 pounds that participated in the triathlon. Talking with several other volunteers, I said that unless they had a signed release from their physician, I would hesitate to let them participate. They countered that as long as people put in their time training, they were fit enough to compete. Good point, but that logic doesn’t really hold up. The primary concern everyone thinks of is cardiovascular disease and that makes sense. But if someone is overweight, the real concern is undiagnosed type 2 diabetes and orthopedic stress.

While I applaud their effort and would never want to prevent anyone from exercising, I would hope that they would have had a thorough medical exam before they took their first step. We can’t assume because they had trained for the race they were actually healthy enough to compete in the race. I’ll cover what those tests should be and a surprise conclusion that you don’t want to miss on Saturday.

What are you prepared to do today?

Dr. Chet