Tag Archive for: eEF2K

Protein and Longevity: The Unproven Relationship

/in /by

I think the best way to assess whether the study I’ve been examining this week on protein and longevity is meaningful or not is to examine the interview with the primary author Christopher Proud, PhD. I’m going to give a series of his statements and whether the research addressed the question.

“Science has shown for some time that eating too much, in particular protein, reduces lifespan; and now we know why.”

This statement isn’t exactly true. While there does seem to be a relationship between calorie restriction and longevity in fruit flies and some species of mice, it hasn’t been proven in humans. There’s evidence in longitudinal studies on relationships between animal protein intake and some diseases, but it’s not accepted that high protein intake leads to an early grave. More likely, there are genetic and environmental factors to consider, but to suggest that eating less overall increases longevity for humans is not correct at this time.

“Eating high-fiber carbohydrate, such as those found in fruit, vegetables, and unprocessed grains and seeds, will produce the healthiest benefits. This is similar to the traditional Mediterranean diet which has well-established links to longevity. We already knew that lower food intake extends lifespan.”

Same as before—it’s an overstatement. There are some studies that show a decreased rate of diseases using the Mediterranean diet, but that doesn’t mean it will result in people living longer. It may mean they live better for the time they’re alive.

“Our team demonstrated that increased [protein] nutrient levels speed up protein synthesis within cells. The faster this process occurs, the more errors are made.”

Based on the way I understand the methods, they did impact protein synthesis by knocking out the eEF2K enzyme. As of this writing, I haven’t heard back from Dr. Proud, so I have yet to find how they overfed the cells, flies, or worms to effect that change.


The Bottom Line

I don’t think that the research done in this series of studies proves that high protein intake decreases longevity. As excited as the corresponding author was during the interview, it wasn’t as clear as he made it out to be. The research didn’t do anything to help set a target goal for human protein intake. How is it supposed to help without practical applications?

What is important is that we need to seek balance in our nutritional intake. It may be true that too much protein will impact the correct production of proteins, which would have long-term effects, and it’s hard to go wrong eating more fruits and vegetables. But longevity isn’t tied to a single nutrient or a single habit. We need to strike a balance. Eat less. Eat better. Move more.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

References: Cell Biology 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.01.029.

Is Protein Bad? The Research

/in /by

Let’s think about this logically. If we wanted to prove that a high-protein diet would decrease lifespan, we would have to feed some type of animal a diet high in protein until all the animals had died. It would be preferable to have animals that don’t live very long such as rodents. Then we compare the lifespans and causes of death with a control group. Simple and straightforward.

That’s not what the research group did. As I said in Tuesday’s Memo, they identified an enzyme called eukaryotic elongation factor 2 kinase (eEF2K) that slows the rate of protein synthesis. That enzyme is also found in C. elegans, a nematode, as well as in fruit flies and humans. They knocked out the eEf2K enzyme, therefore causing protein synthesis to happen faster. This is supposed to be what happens when too much protein is eaten. They noted more mistakes in protein synthesis as a result.

The methodology for this series of experiments is beyond my expertise. By a lot. Whether the research was on cancer cell lines, the nematodes, or the fruit flies, what I could not find in the Methods section is where they added protein or amino acids to the food for any culture or animal to mimic a high-protein diet. I wrote to the study’s lead author to see if my analysis was correct, but I haven’t gotten a response yet.

What does all this mean? I’ll wrap it up on Saturday.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Reference: Cell Biology 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.01.029/

Does Protein Decrease Lifespan?

/in /by

Just when we’ve accepted that carbohydrates are bad for us and everyone seems to be doing the paleo or ketogenic diets, a new study from an Australian research group created headlines by suggesting that high-protein diets are unhealthy because they decrease longevity.

For years we’ve been told that high-fat diets are bad. Then scientists suggested that it’s carbohydrates that are bad, which led to this keto-everything dietary phase we’re in right now. Now we’re being told that high-protein diets are bad for us as well? What the heck are we supposed to eat? Before we panic, let’s take a look at the research to see if it’s meaningful or not.

Researchers identified an enzyme called eukaryotic elongation factor 2 kinase (eEF2K) that slows the rate of protein synthesis. By so doing, it reduces the number of mistakes made in making or folding proteins. If a long-chain protein such as insulin has mistakes in the location of amino acids, the protein will not work as it should. When you consider the number of proteins the body has to make to function every second, too many mistakes could lead to disease and thus reduce our lifespan.

Is this real? Let’s take a look at how the research was conducted to figure out whether we have to be concerned or not.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Reference: Cell Biology 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.01.029/