Let’s finish the week with a question no one asked but was the topic of a recent study: what’s better for your health—being a weekend warrior or working out according to established guidelines? The major component of the guidelines is more than 150 minutes of moderate to intense exercise a week spread out over most days of the week. Turns out, they are both effective, but let’s take a closer look.

The Study

The UK Biobank data are connected to the medical records of all people in the UK, making it an excellent source for studies. This observational study used data collected on close to 90,000 subjects who wore an accelerometer for a week sometime between 2013 and 2015; they were tracked for at least six years. Researchers tracked the diagnosis of over 678 conditions and compared those who exceeded the minimum of 150 minutes of moderate to intense exercise, either over a weekend or stretched over a week, with those who exercised fewer minutes.

The weekend warriors had reduced Hazard Ratios for 264 conditions and regular weekday activity had reduced Hazard Ratios for 205. Most of the benefits were associated with cardiometabolic metrics such as hypertension, resting heart rate, and type 2 diabetes. When compared head-to-head, there were no conditions where the weekend warriors and the regular exercisers differed.

What Should I Do?

I wouldn’t change anything you’re currently doing as long as you’re getting more than 150 minutes of moderate to intense exercise every week. We don’t know the activities involved in either—just that the accelerometer showed they were moving.

What it can mean is that for those who are playing basketball or soccer for a couple of hours a day on the weekends, you’re getting some benefit. It also means if you have a two-hour trail walk you like to do on weekends, it can help reduce your risk of cardiometabolic diseases.

The Bottom Line

What I really think it illustrates is that any movement is good movement, and if you can’t work in as much exercise as you’d like during the week, you can make up for it on the weekend. I would have liked to have seen the different activities involved and any orthopedic injuries associated with the activities, but let’s take the win. Just get moving and stay moving during the week or packed into a weekend. Or—maybe—both! Go get ’em, you warriors!

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Reference: https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.124.068669