Tag Archive for: bone health

Maintaining Bone Health

/in /by

In trying to live every day we’re alive, I’ve spent a lot of time talking about the ability to move, but it’s not just about muscle. Those muscles connect to bones for the most part, and the bones must be healthy as well. One of the basic tenets of healthy bones is Wolfe’s law, which can be summarized as “function determines structure.” In everyday terms, to have healthy bones you must stress them regularly. Exercise is critical to that effort. But it’s not as simple as that.

Hormones and nutrients are also critical to bone health. Our ability to make hormones and absorb and utilize nutrients diminishes as we get older. Hormone replacement therapy has been controversial, and that’s a discussion a woman should have with her physician. In terms of nutrients, the ones critical to healthy bones are calcium, magnesium, vitamin D, and vitamin K2.

Before increasing any nutrients via supplements, have a bone-density test as well as a vitamin D test. If either test has low results, then taking a combination of the nutrients mentioned earlier would help the bones when combined with exercise. Any exercise that’s weight bearing is beneficial such as walking, but not swimming, with added benefits for weight training.

Maybe the best we can do is to stop the loss of bone mass, but that will help you live better for longer. We’ll move from bones to joints on Thursday.

What are you prepared to do today?

        Dr. Chet

Why Nutrition Is a Process

/in /by

A celebrity doctor who specializes in cancer treatment said something that caught my attention, and it goes to this question: why are some people cured by specific treatments while others don’t respond at all? In his opinion, it’s because the cancer creates a new system in the body that competes with the other systems.

The new system may be different in each body once the cancer is established, which could mean that everyone really requires an individual approach. A systems approach would be necessary only if the cancer gets too established; early diagnosis can use treatments that work in most people. Late diagnosis means the cancer has established a system with strengths and weaknesses that are unknown. But the systems approach isn’t limited to cancer.

What’s a Systems Approach?

A systems approach is simply this: we attempt to reach a goal by looking at the interactive nature and interdependence of all the factors in an entity.

Here’s an analogy: you flip the switch for the light in your kitchen, but the light doesn’t go on. What could be wrong? The light won’t work if:

  • Your bulb is burned out
  • Your circuit breaker needs to be reset
  • An electrical outlet somewhere has a tripped GFCI
  • Your switch has gone bad
  • A wire is loose in your light fixture
  • The power is out to your whole house

Turning on a light is easy—my grandson Riley is very good at it and he’s not even three. But if it’s not working, you have to look at each element of the system to find the problem and get the kitchen light back on.

How Vitamin D is Part of Your Bone Health System

While osteoporosis or weight gain doesn’t create a new system like cancer does, there are numerous steps in both processes. On top of that, if we’ve been on the path to bone loss or weight gain, there may be changes in normal metabolism that have to be overcome.

Let me explain using vitamin D for bone health. Whether we make vitamin D in our skin, get it from food, or take it in supplement form, it has to be processed by the liver to become the active form to promote bone growth. If there’s a defect in getting the raw vitamin D from food or a supplement into the bloodstream and on to the liver, not enough vitamin D would be made into the active form. Or there may be a defect in the processing of the raw vitamin D once it gets to the liver. Or there may a defect in the receptor for the active vitamin D on the target tissue. I could go on and on about where issues could occur, but I hope you get the point. Right now, we have no idea where the issue might be for the use of vitamin D in an individual just as we don’t know where the weak point of a cancer system might be and thus where we should attack.

Do we quit? No. We simply use a systems approach—we look at every step necessary to reach our goal and what we can do at each step. We begin with taking vitamin D for a specific period of time. We then get re-tested, most likely a bone density scan. If there’s growth, great. If there’s not, then we either add more D or add calcium or switch to a different form of calcium. Then retest. If that doesn’t work we can add vitamin C or glucosamine, both critical to the manufacture of connective tissue. There are other factors such as smoking and exercise that also impact bone growth. We systematically add new variables or add more of some that we’re already doing. Might this take a long time? Yes. Would we have to pay attention? Yes. But is it a natural approach to complicated conditions? Again, yes. No matter what the condition, if you’re going to try to deal with it nutritionally, that’s the approach you’ll have to take. You have to find what works for you.

The Bottom Line on Vitamin D

The systems approach goes a long way to explain why some people benefitted from vitamin D and calcium to prevent fractures and others did not. The only fact the meta-analysis study proves is that vitamin D and calcium supplementation don’t work for everyone. The key is to move on to the next approach; it may be different supplements or it may even be a medication. More options must be tried until a solution is found for each individual.

Over time, I’m going to continue to explore this concept of a systems approach to nutrition. I have no idea where it will lead, but it’s worth spending more time thinking and researching it.

What are you prepared to do today?

Dr. Chet

 

Reference: JAMA. 2017;318(24):2466-2482. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.19344.

 

You Actually Have to Take the Supplements

/in /by

The authors of the study on calcium and vitamin D supplementation as they relate to fractures were all orthopedic surgeons, as stated in the paper. They had no known training in nutrition. Maybe not statistics either.

When you perform a meta-analysis, each research study included is given a weight in the form of a percentage, which indicates how much it contributed to the outcome. Not all studies should contribute equally; that helps to eliminate the bias of a tremendous benefit in a very small study versus a large study with no benefit. They didn’t seem to read something in three studies that contributed close to 90% of the analysis (2-4): the authors of those papers said that the reduction in fractures did occur, or at least bone was restored, when the subjects took over 80% of the doses of calcium and vitamin D they were supposed to take. The problem: average compliance was around 50%.

What these surgeons could have done was tease out the data on those subjects who were compliant and analyzed that data. What they might have had were results that demonstrated that in order to get a benefit, subjects had to take the supplements regularly. That would have been meaningful. Instead, inexperience or ignorance left us with headlines but little else.

Still, there are some questions that were raised in my mind and I’ll cover them on Saturday. But one thing won’t change: if you’re going to take supplements of any kind, you’ve got to actually take them if you want a benefit.

What are you prepared to do today?

Dr. Chet

 

References:
1. JAMA. 2017;318(24):2466-2482. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.19344.
2. Lancet. 2005;365(9471): 1621-1628.
3. Arch Intern Med. 2006;166(8):869-875.
4. Am J Med. 2006;119(9):777-785.

 

Are Vitamin D and Calcium Still Worth Taking?

/in /by

Maybe you recently read a headline that went something like this: “Vitamin D and Calcium Do Not Prevent Fractures.” Many headlines were much worse. Over this past weekend I read the research paper published in JAMA. Is it real? Should you not bother taking your calcium and vitamin D to protect your bones? No—keep taking them. But it does give me an opportunity to talk about some of the issues surrounding these types of papers as well as the complexity of nutrition for our health. That’s our topic this week.

The study was a meta-analysis of studies that examined the relationship between the risk of fractures in elderly populations and supplementation with calcium, vitamin D, and both supplements together. After a rigorous database search, 33 randomized controlled trials were included in the meta-analysis. Some studies lasted several months, and some lasted several years. The amounts of calcium and vitamin D in the supplements varied in every study. After analysis, the researchers determined that neither calcium nor vitamin D nor the combination of both reduced the rate of fractures when compared to placebo. That led to their conclusions.

This was a mess as you probably guessed with differing quantities and lengths of the trials. What bothered me most was that if they really understood nutrition as well as the results of the studies they included, they could have done something special. I’ll cover that on Thursday.

What are you prepared to do today?

Dr. Chet

 

Reference: JAMA. 2017;318(24):2466-2482. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.19344.

 

Variances in Calcium Absorption

/in /by

On top of the calcium absorption issues discussed in Tuesday’s message, there are a few more factors that have to be considered. In healthy women, gross absorption efficiency spans at least a threefold range, from 15% to 45%, even after adjustment for differences in intake.

Here’s an example. One woman, absorbing at 45% efficiency, extracts 135 mg of the calcium in an 8-ounce serving of milk containing 300 mg of calcium and after subtracting the calcium used in digestion, her net calcium is 100 mg. But another woman absorbing at 15% efficiency extracts only 45 mg and . . .

We're sorry, but this content is available to Members and Insiders only.

If you're already a DrChet.com Member or Insider, click on the Membership Login link on the top menu. Members may upgrade to Insider by going to the Store and clicking Membership; your membership fee will be prorated automatically.